Amazon Renewed, Amazon Resale and Used Listings: What They Pay, What Returns Do to Them, and When a Refurbished Pick Belongs in a Guide
A reader with $600 who wants a $900 laptop has one honest answer, and it's not a worse laptop: it's the same laptop, refurbished, with a guarantee. Most buyer guides don't say so, partly because the writer didn't think of it and partly because of a vague worry that refurbished listings don't pay or can't be linked.
They pay, they can, and in some categories a labelled refurbished option is the most useful section on the page. In others it's a liability, and the difference is knowable.
This post covers the three kinds of non-new listing on Amazon and how each shows up, whether they pay commission and on what, the return rate and what it does to the month, the categories where a refurbished pick belongs in a guide and the categories where it doesn't, how to link to a Renewed product (a listing) rather than a used unit (an offer that will be gone), and how to word the section so the reader knows what they're buying.
The rates post has the category rates; the same table applies here, on a smaller number.
The short answer
Renewed, Amazon Resale and used offers all pay the normal category rate on the price paid. Renewed is a listing you can recommend; Resale and used are single units that disappear.
Add a labelled "refurbished option" section in categories where grading is reliable and the saving is large (phones, laptops, cameras, tools); leave it out where wear can't be judged or the battery is the product. Expect more returns on that section and read it after returns. Never make the refurbished unit the top pick.
The three kinds
| Amazon Renewed | Amazon Resale (was Amazon Warehouse) | Third-party used | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Refurbished by vetted sellers, inspected and tested, sold under Amazon's Renewed programme | Amazon's own resale of returns and open-box stock, graded Like New to Acceptable | Individual sellers' used units under "Other sellers" |
| Guarantee | Renewed Guarantee: 90 days (US), one year on Renewed Premium | Amazon's standard return window | Seller's terms, within Amazon's A-to-z protection |
| How it's listed | Its own product listing, "(Renewed)" in the title, usually with several sellers | An offer on the new product's page, or the Resale storefront | An offer on the new product's page |
| Stable enough to link? | Yes; a listing with ongoing stock | No; a specific unit that sells once | No; same |
| Pays commission? | Yes, category rate on the Renewed price | Yes, category rate on the price paid | Yes, category rate on the price paid |
| Return rate | Higher than new | Higher still | Varies; often highest |
| Belongs in a guide? | As a labelled option, in the right categories | Only as a "check Resale for open-box" line | No |
The linking row decides most of it. A Renewed product has a listing of its own that stays live as sellers restock; you can link it the way you link anything.
A Resale or used unit is one item at one price that someone else will buy this afternoon, and a link to it either lands on the new product's buy box (earning on the new price, confusing the reader who was promised a saving) or on an offer that's gone.
What they pay
The commission rate is set by the product's category and applied to the price paid, and nothing in the Operating Agreement treats refurbished differently. So a Renewed phone earns the electronics rate on the Renewed price: the same percentage, a smaller number.
The expensive products post covers why that still beats a cheap new pick: 4% of a $550 Renewed laptop is $22, which is more than 4% of a new $400 budget laptop, and the reader got the better machine. The refurbished section isn't a charity line; it often earns more per click than the budget pick it sits beside.
What returns do to it
Refurbished items come back more often than new ones. Grading is a range ("Excellent" covers a lot), buyers' expectations vary, and a unit that arrives with more wear than the reader pictured goes back. Every return reverses the commission, so a refurbished section's effective rate is lower than its earned rate by more than the rest of the page's.
The returns post covers how that shows up in the reports; for this section, read the Earnings report after the return window, give it its own tracking ID so you can see it on its own, and set expectations in the text (what the grade means, what the guarantee covers) because the better the reader's expectations match the unit, the fewer come back.
Which categories
| Refurbished pick belongs | Why | Leave it out | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phones, tablets, laptops | Large saving, reliable grading, battery stated on Premium, the reader expects the option | Earbuds, smartwatches, cordless vacuums | Battery health is the product and grading doesn't disclose it |
| Cameras and lenses | Shutter count and glass condition are gradable; big saving | Mattresses, bedding, anything hygiene-related | Wear can't be judged and the reader doesn't want to |
| Power tools | Durable, testable, and the saving is real on brand tools | Car seats, helmets, safety gear | Unknown history on a safety product |
| Premium over-ear headphones, speakers | Testable; pads are replaceable | Small appliances under $60 | The saving is a few dollars and the return risk isn't worth it |
| Monitors, networking gear | Works or doesn't; easy to verify on arrival | Anything where "Acceptable" grade is common | The reader's picture and the unit won't match |
Linking it
- Link the Renewed listing, the one with "(Renewed)" in the title, not a used offer on the new product's page. Search Amazon for the product name plus "renewed" and take that listing's URL. Link the thing the sentence describes.
- Name the grade if the listing offers several ("Excellent", "Premium"), and link the one you mean.
- Don't link Resale or used units. A "check Amazon Resale for open-box units" sentence with a link to the new listing is honest; a link to one unit isn't, because it won't be there.
- Give the section its own tracking ID so returns on it don't blur the rest of the guide.
- Price and availability through the API, as with any pick; Renewed stock moves, and a guide that says "about 40% less" needs to be checked.
Wording the section
- Label it plainly: "The refurbished option" as the heading, not folded into the main list.
- Say what Renewed means in one sentence: inspected and tested by a vetted seller, with Amazon's Renewed Guarantee (90 days, or a year on Premium).
- Say what varies: cosmetic wear within the grade, accessories possibly generic, battery capacity on older units unless Premium.
- Say who it's for: the reader who wants this product and not a cheaper new one, and can live with a scuff.
- Never make it the top pick. It's an option beside the pick, for a reader with a budget, not the verdict.
- No "like new" from you. The grade is Amazon's word; yours is "refurbished, graded Excellent".
Doing it with AffSERP
Guides written by AffSERP's X Best Review tool select picks from new listings by default, which is right for the verdict and the main list.
A refurbished option is a section you add in the editor: find the Renewed listing, link it with your tag, and write the five lines above; the tool's own sections already carry the price and availability through Amazon's API, so the saving you quote against the new pick stays current when the Refresh option runs.
In the categories in the left column of the table, it's the most useful ten minutes you can add to a guide.
FAQ
Do Amazon affiliate links pay commission on Renewed or used products?
Yes, at the product's normal category rate, on the price actually paid. A Renewed laptop at $600 earns the same percentage as a new one at $900, so the commission is lower because the price is, not because the item is refurbished. Amazon Resale (the renamed Amazon Warehouse) and third-party used offers pay the same way. The one thing to watch is that a Renewed or used offer is a separate listing or a separate offer on the listing, so your link has to land on it for the reader to buy it; a link to the new listing's buy box earns on the new price if the reader buys there.
What's the difference between Amazon Renewed and Amazon Resale?
Renewed is Amazon's programme for refurbished products sold by vetted third-party sellers: inspected, tested, backed by the Amazon Renewed Guarantee (90 days in the US, a year for Premium), and listed as 'Renewed' in the title. Amazon Resale, called Amazon Warehouse until August 2024, is Amazon's own resale of returned and open-box items, graded Like New through Acceptable, with Amazon's standard return policy. Third-party used offers are individual sellers under the 'Other sellers' or 'Used' options. Renewed is the one that behaves like a product you can recommend; the other two are single units that may be gone by the time the reader clicks.
Should I recommend refurbished products in a buyer guide?
In some categories, as a clearly labelled option, yes: phones, laptops, tablets, cameras, power tools and premium headphones are categories where Renewed units are common, well graded and a real saving, and where a reader on a budget wants to know the option exists. Not in categories where the reader has no way to judge wear (mattresses, anything hygiene-related, car seats), where battery health is the whole product (earbuds, smartwatches, cordless vacuums) and the grading doesn't disclose it, or where the saving is small. Label it, explain the guarantee, and never make it the top pick.
Do refurbished products have a higher return rate?
Yes, noticeably, which matters because a returned order reverses your commission. Renewed items run a higher return rate than new ones because expectations vary and grading is a range; Amazon Resale open-box items run higher still. On a guide with a refurbished section, expect that section's effective commission to be lower than its earned commission by more than the rest of the page's, and read it in the Earnings report after returns, not in the Orders report.
AffSERP guides carry each new pick's price through Amazon's API, so the saving a refurbished section quotes against it stays current on every Refresh.
Start with free words